Mennonite Mutual Aid Society

Mennonite Mutual Aid Society (MMAS) writes insurance for wind, fire, hail and extended coverage for dwellings, farms and churches in Ohio.  Along with quality personal attention, MMAS coverage is provided through the following local, independent agencies:


Swiss Mutual Insurance Agency – Bethany Theis, Agent

208 South Main Street, Bluffton, Ohio
Phone – (419)-358-7585;  E-Mail

Sprunger Insurance Agency – Nathan Sprunger, Agent

114 East Main Street, Pandora, Ohio
Phone – (419)-384-3286;  E-Mail


Mennonite Mutual Aid Society (MMAS) was formed in 1866 by four Mennonite churches in Allen, Hancock, Hardin and Putnam counties of Ohio to assist people in need after a catastrophic loss.

In 1907, MMAS was incorporated and started operating under the Ohio Revised Code 3939 as an assessment company.

In 2013, MMAS became affiliated with Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company of Orrville, Ohio. As a result of the affiliation, MMAS has transitioned from a post-assessment company (where policyholders were invoiced for their previous 12 months of insurance coverage on September 1st) to an advanced premium collection (where policyholders are invoiced in advance -per a unique renewal date – for their next 12 months of insurance coverage).