No one wants a claim.  Unfortunately there are times when a loss is experienced by a policyholder. It may be a fire destroying the lifelong investment of a home, the theft of possessions or the threat of legal action due to another’s injury.

Whatever the case may be, when a loss is sustained, our Claims Department becomes your ally. The goal of the Claims Department at Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company is to provide efficient and prompt service fairly, accurately and within the framework of the policy.

Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company enjoys long-term relationships with our policyholders through working toward this goal.

To make the initial report of a possible claim, please call your agent. Refer to our Agency Locator Map for help finding an agency near you.

In the event of an after-hours claims emergency, the Claims Department at Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company can be reached directly at 1-800-678-6885 (extension 120). You can also submit a claim via email at